Guest editor for twoissue symposium on philosophy between the lines. Above all, the question displayed the same credulous attitude. The most important philosophers were socrates, plato, and aristotle. Philosophy between the lines beantwortet bereits im ersten teil the two basic questions of this book. After attending the kirchhain volksschule and the protestant rektoratsschule, leo strauss was enrolled at the gymnasium philippinum affiliated with the university of marburg in nearby marburg from which johannes althusius and carl j. Melzer is a most useful book, without peer as an introduction to the writing and reading of philosophy understood as esoteric rationalism. Beginning with homer and ending with wittgenstein, i present here in chronological order all the major. Melzers book is a masterful treatment of the lost history of esoteric writing from socrates to the present day. I mean he didnt even distinguish between evolution within a species and evolution between species. Oct 31, 2014 theres much to recommend in each of these books. Review of melzer philosophy between the lines2 author. Contemporary political theory as an antienlightenment project. Socrates, plato, and aristotle introduction between the years 469 322 b.
Philosophy between the lines this book list for those who looking for to read and enjoy the philosophy between the lines, you can read or download pdf epub books and dont forget to give credit to the trailblazing authors. The lost history of esoteric writing, by arthur melzer. Philosophical esotericism the practice of communicating ones unorthodox thoughts between the lines was a common practice until the end of the eighteenth. Melzers book philosophy between the lines does not fall into the morass of vehemently pro or antistrauss rhetoric. Melzer makes clear that the topic is important and his book is so well written, cogently argued, and thoroughly researched that it will be of great interest to readers in intellectual history, history of philosophy, and all. Melzer argues, following strauss, that the true history of human reason is of necessity a secret history. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading philosophy between the lines. But the book is much more than a catalogue of evidence, says francis fukuyama. Melzers book is the best study we haveor are likely to haveon the theme of esoteric writing. Philosophical esotericismthe practice of communicating ones unorthodox thoughts between the lineswas a common practice until.
Jul 18, 2015 arthur melzer, philosophy between the lines. The lost history of esoteric writing, a remarkably straightforward and somewhat doctrinaire defense and history of esotericism. Such a distinction was crucial, even in heideggers early writings, because theology is, in heideggers words, a positive science, i. You might say that esotericism is the philosophy, or the science, of the evolutionary process, as it pertains to the human and the subhuman kingdoms. While cort ammon and others have given good definitional answers, these are more about the nature of axiomatic systems, while i suspect what is wanted is more along the lines of, what is a straight line really. Before reading philosophy between the lines, i myself was not welldisposed toward the practice of esoteric reading. On the evidence provided by melzers philosophy between the lines, the resounding answer to all the above is yes. The lost history of esoteric writing kindle edition by melzer, arthur m download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. He didnt wonder what it would mean to believe in a hypothesis.
Philosophy between the lines is the first comprehensive, booklength study of the history and theoretical basis of philosophical esotericism, and it provides a crucial guide to how many major writingsphilosophical, but also theological, political, and literarywere. After attending the kirchhain volksschule and the protestant rektoratsschule, leo strauss was enrolled at the gymnasium philippinum affiliated with the university. And rousseaus unpublished preface from his second letter to bordes, which 85 melzer relies on several times 16, 112, 118, 255, is by no means clear evidence of esotericism, especially when read in textual context. In the books final section, a beginners guide to esoteric reading, melzer turns to how we might once again cultivate the longforgotten art of reading esoteric works. Roger smith explains why you could love arthur melzers book, philosophy between the lines, know that esotericism is real, and still be a political progressive. I am currently beginning a book project that will seek to defend the enlightenment to. Esotericism includes every form of secretiveness in the 30 communication of thought 368. Philosophy between the lines, or through dubious signs. Melzer makes clear that the topic is important and his book is so well written, cogently argued, and thoroughly researched that it will be of great interest to readers in intellectual history, history of philosophy, and all related disciplines. Philosophy between the lines, lecture at department of economics, george mason university, september 16, 2015. Enter arthur melzer, who provides, in philosophy between the lines. Thomas jefferson, natures god, and the theological. Foreword to republication of the educational benefits of. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading philosophy between the.
The lost history of esoteric writing, arthur melzer explains that implausible blunders, errors of fact, and misquotations have been common techniques of esoteric writing melzer, 2014, p. But for my money, the best by far is arthur melzer s just published study, philosophy between the lines. Melzer is the author of philosophy between the lines 4. This is for a variety of reasons, the most prominent being esoteric writings close association with the scholar primarily responsible for its 20thcentury rediscovery, leo strauss. He didnt distinguish between evolution as a first or final cause, and evolution as an efficient cause. The document on this website is an online appendix for philosophy between the lines. Roger smith explains why you could love arthur melzer s book, philosophy between the lines, know that esotericism is real, and still be a political progressive. Melzers book emphasizes the puzzle that while ancient thinkers were quite open about esotericism, modern thinkers have mostly forgotten it ever existed, and are typically indignantly dismissive when the. Philosophy between the lines is the first comprehensive, booklength study of the history and theoretical basis of philosophical esotericism, and it provides a crucial guide to how many major writingsphilosophical, but also theological. Philosophy between the lines, hillsdale college, april 2015. Political realism and political philosophy in jeanjacques.
The ageless wisdom teachings, or esotericism as it is often called, is not a religion. The lost history of esoteric writing by melzer, arthur m. It does not constitute the discovery, or recapture, of the great books and of. Philosophy between the lines is the first comprehensive, booklength study of the history and theoretical basis of philosophical esotericism. The lost history of esoteric writing, by michigan state political scientist arthur melzer vindicates the straussian view that. Sep 24, 2014 a new book philosophy between the lines. A successful reevaluation of strausss writings on esotericism would thus prove invaluable to the evaluation both of strausss own work and of the phe nomenon known as straussianism. It is a fine line between reason and rationalization.
Intellectuals discussed logic, reason, law, religion, nature, and metaphysics. The lost history of esoteric writing by arthur melzer. I am aware that the argument of this paper that the majority of contemporary political theorists seek to dissociate themselves from the enlightenment isnt actually much of an argument. Philosophy between the lines is the first comprehensive, booklength study of the history and theoretical basis of philosophical esotericism, and it provides a crucial guide to how many major writingsphilosophical, but also theological, political, and literarywere composed prior to the nineteenth epub century. Philosophical esotericismthe practice of communicating ones unorthodox thoughts between the lineswas a common practice until the end of the eighteenth. The select works of william penn vol 5 of 5 classic reprint. The lost history of esoteric writing, university of chicago press, 2014, 453pp. Philosophy between the lines download pdfepub ebook. Oct 20, 2015 this motto, often attributed to the roman satirist petronius, was often used to explain why people turn to religion.
Augustine rejected this idea city of god, 27, but arthur melzer cites charles blount who uses it to point to why the philosopher should read between the lines melzer 2014, p. Contemporary political theory as an antienlightenment project nb. For this is simply another way of saying that it is the. However, this book has convinced me that any attempt to read the history of philosophy without being willing. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. But for my money, the best by far is arthur melzers just published study, philosophy between the.
1602 985 551 1526 1204 1230 441 467 848 727 1645 1177 446 79 886 1375 719 116 625 1355 435 739 982 1059 84 909 1233 740 832 882 1186 576 1100